You agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy by your Additional Use of this site.

Qualified Settlement Trusts vs. Qualified Settlement Funds (QSF)

June 27, 2024

Dive into the realm of Qualified Settlement Trusts and Funds. Learn their definitions, uses, benefits, implementation procedures, and real-world implications. Discover how QSFs can transform the settlement process in various legal conflicts.

Shakespeare wrote, ‘What’s in a name?’ In the realm of qualified settlement administration, maybe quite a lot – or nothing at all.

It is essential for legal, settlement, and financial experts to grasp the nuances of Qualified Settlement Funds (QSF). A QSF, also called a 468B fund, serves as a mechanism for parties to settle disputes while reaping tax advantages and benefiting from extra planning time and deferred taxation.

Understanding the principles and uses of QSFs can significantly influence the outcome of settlement talks and the contentment of all parties involved.

This paper explores the realm of Qualified Settlement Funds and their namesake “Qualified Settlement Trusts.” This paper delves into their definitions, practical scenarios, implementation procedures, and real-world implications.

Whether a financial consultant or an involved party, this paper equips you with the knowledge needed to maximize QSF benefits in a settlement agreement.

Is a Qualified Settlement Trust a Qualified Settlement Fund (QSF)?

The answer is - Well, maybe.

When established by a government authority, a Qualified Settlement Fund must meet all the requirements of 26 USC § 468B, et seq., and 26 CFR § 1.468B-1, et seq. It also enables defendants to deposit payments into the QSF trust in exchange for a release of liability.

So, while some may informally call a QSF a Qualified Settlement Trust, the only test that matters is whether the Trust (whatever its name) meets the requirements of 26 USC § 468B, et seq., and § 1.468B-1, et seq. If it does, it is a QSF, no matter what informal label or name is applied to it.

lawyer holding QSF documents

Key Characteristics

For a Qualified Settlement Trust to be a QSF, it must:

  • Have the approval of a governmental authority and continue under the approving governmental authority’s jurisdiction;
  • Settle one or more disputed or undisputed claims arising from an event (or a related series of events) connected to torts, contract breaches, or other legal violations provided for in § 1.468B-1, et seq.; and
  • Separate the assets from the transferor through a separate trust created under state law or through physically segregating the funds.

When Is It Beneficial to Use a Qualified Settlement Trust?

Qualified Settlement Trusts constructed as QSFs prove valuable in resolving legal conflicts.

Some common situations may include:

  • Cases involving personal injury, product liability, drugs, and sexual abuse;
  • Wrongful death cases where there are disagreements among heirs or issues with distributing assets;
  • Cases that involve future claimants when unknown lien holders, especially when the timing and amounts of future claims are uncertain;
  • Post-settlement, when secondary disputes exist, and
  • When additional time is needed to execute financial planning properly.

In these scenarios, QSFs offer advantages such as preventing conflicts of interest for lawyers, allowing plaintiffs to earn interest while disputes are resolved, and freeing defendants from battles while addressing liens and other matters.

Requirements to Implement a Qualified Settlement Fund

Create a trust agreement outlining the QSF rules, detailing how distributions should operate, and setting out the trustee’s duties.

Government approval is required to establish the QSF. The governmental authority that approves the QSF will appoint a trustee to manage it. This approval should clearly define the purpose of the QSF. A proper QSF should also specify the types of claims it aims to resolve.

Once approved, obtaining an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the Internal Revenue Service for the QSF is imperative.

QSF 360 displayed over city

Real World Examples

  • Eastern Point Trust Company’s online platform—QSF 360—played a role in resolving the Volkswagen “Dieselgate” scandal through a QSF created to compensate vehicle owners.
  • Additionally, the same QSF 360 platform played a vital role in California’s wildfire settlement administration.
  • A multi-million-dollar wrongful death case with multiple surviving minors also benefited from QSF 360 by allowing additional time to work with the family and courts to plan for their financial future.

These practical instances and tens of thousands of other uses highlight how versatile and successful are QSFs are in managing settlements regardless of the number of parties or type of industry.

Conclusion

The inception and application of Qualified Settlement Trusts (properly designed and approved as a Qualified Settlement Fund) can transformed how large and small legal conflicts are settled. By offering a tax-efficient method for handling settlement funds, QSFs streamline distribution processes. The real-world examples underscore QSFs’ role in resolving simple and complex legal battles across diverse sectors.

With the legal environment constantly changing, the significance of Qualified Settlement Trusts as a QSF in resolving disputes is ever-expanding.

For a comprehensive overview of tax minimization strategies, see our guide on minimizing tax liability on lawsuit settlements.

Learn how the Plaintiff Recovery Trust addresses the attorney fee double tax created by Commissioner v. Banks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Under IRC § 61, all income from whatever source derived is taxable unless a specific exclusion applies. Lawsuit settlements are included in gross income by default. The key exceptions are physical injury and physical sickness recoveries under IRC § 104(a)(2), which are excluded from gross income when received as compensation for a physical injury or physical sickness claim.

IRC § 104(a)(2) excludes from gross income damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness. The exclusion applies to compensatory damages only. The injury or sickness must be physical — emotional distress damages, employment discrimination recoveries, breach of contract proceeds, and punitive damages do not qualify for the exclusion and are taxable.

Yes. Punitive damages are taxable as ordinary income regardless of whether the underlying claim involves a physical injury. IRC § 104(a)(2) does not exclude punitive damages. Even in a physical injury case where compensatory damages are excluded, any punitive damages awarded are included in the plaintiff's gross income and subject to federal income tax.

For most plaintiffs, no. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 suspended miscellaneous itemized deductions under IRC § 67(g) for tax years 2018 through 2025, eliminating the attorney fee deduction for most civil litigation recoveries. IRC § 62(a)(20) provides an above-the-line deduction only for qualifying discrimination and whistleblower cases. Plaintiffs in personal injury, breach of contract, and most tort cases cannot deduct attorney fees under current law.

A Qualified Settlement Fund (QSF) under IRC § 468B separates the timing of the defendant's payment from the plaintiff's taxable receipt of funds. The defendant transfers proceeds to the QSF and takes an immediate tax deduction. The plaintiff does not recognize taxable income until distribution from the QSF, preserving a planning window to implement structured settlements, Plaintiff Recovery Trusts, Special Needs Trusts, or other tax-minimization strategies before receiving taxable income.

A Plaintiff Recovery Trust (PRT), administered by Eastern Point Trust Company, addresses the attorney fee double tax created by Commissioner v. Banks, 543 U.S. 426 (2005), and worsened by TCJA 2017. The PRT separates the attorney fee portion of the settlement from the plaintiff's taxable recovery, allowing each party to recognize income only on their respective portion. Eastern Point Trust Company has saved plaintiffs $30 million or more through PRT structures. The PRT is implemented during the QSF administration window before taxable distributions occur.

You Have Needs,
We Have Expertise

Discover trust and settlement solutions you won’t find anywhere else – thoughtfully designed to protect assets, simplify processes, and deliver peace of mind.
Expert guidance, every step of the way.

Contact Us
By submitting this form, you agree to be contacted by Eastern Point Trust Company, as well as agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.