The Plaintiff Double Tax: A Permanent Tax Problem with a Practical Solution
But they pay tax as though they did.
This is not hypothetical.
This is every taxable settlement in the modern era.
Understanding the Plaintiff Double Tax
The Solution — Plaintiff Recovery Trust
EPTC, in conjunction with other highly respected tax professionals, developed and administers the PRT. It is available with no setup cost and can be established quickly once a case is identified as a candidate. The PRT uses a specialized trust structure — adapted from established charitable planning techniques — designed to realign the tax treatment of plaintiff recoveries with the economic reality of how proceeds are distributed.
How It Works
Step 1
Establish the PRT early. The claim is transferred to the Plaintiff Recovery Trust before final resolution. The PRT can be established quickly with no setup fee.
Step 2
Case resolves. Whether through litigation or settlement, the recovery is paid to the PRT. The PRT is compatible with structured settlements for both plaintiff and attorney, and with cases involving both taxable and tax-free recoveries.
Step 3
PRT distributes proceeds. When there is a recovery, it is paid to the PRT. The PRT pays the plaintiff their net share and the attorney their fee — preserving the economic deal while restructuring the tax recognition.
Step 4
Tax recognition shifts. Taxation on amounts the plaintiff does not receive is eliminated from the plaintiff’s income recognition — thereby reducing the taxation to the plaintiff. The structure realigns tax recognition with the economic reality of how proceeds are actually distributed.
Step 5
The plaintiff is taxed on net recovery only. The plaintiff’s taxable income reflects what they actually received, resulting in meaningful tax savings and a significantly improved after-tax result. The economic deal between plaintiff and attorney remains intact throughout.
Representative Case Outcomes
The supporting chart and data following.
| Case Type | Gross Recovery | Attorney Fee (40%) | PRT Contrib. (3%) | Tax Without PRT | Tax With PRT | Tax Savings | Net Proceeds Increase* |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 — Business Fraud / Breach of Contract | $750,000 | $300,000 | $22,500 | $262,500‡ | $149,625‡ | $112,875 | +48% |
| Case 2 — Securities Litigation | $2,000,000 | $800,000 | $60,000 | $820,000§ | $467,400§ | $352,600 | +77% |
| Case 3 — IP Infringement / Defamation | $5,000,000 | $2,000,000 | $150,000 | $2,000,000 | $1,140,000 | $860,000 | +71% |
| Case 4 — Punitive Damages + Pre-Judgment Interest† | $12,000,000 | $4,800,000 | $360,000 | $5,400,000† | $3,078,000† | $2,322,000 | +109% |
The Financial Case — Illustrated
Income Tax Paid by Plaintiff
Total federal & state income tax on the plaintiff's recovery. Without PRT (Red), plaintiff is taxed on the full gross recovery including attorney fees. The PRT reduces taxes significantly (Green).
↓ Tax Reduction Achieved with PRT
Net After-Tax Proceeds to Plaintiff
The plaintiff's net proceeds after attorney fees. The PRT eliminates taxation of contingent attorney fees, significantly increasing the plaintiff's net proceeds. (Red = without PRT, Green = with PRT)
↑ Net Proceeds Increase with PRT
Additional Net Proceeds the Plaintiff Gains Through the PRT
Additional after-tax dollars the plaintiff receives by using a PRT. Calculated as Net Proceeds With PRT minus Net Proceeds Without PRT. Percentage labels show the proportional gain. These are dollars lost to double-tax treatment under current law without the PRT.
↑ Total Additional Dollars Recovered Through the PRT
Hypothetical Illustrations Only. These figures do not reflect actual client outcomes and are for illustrative purposes only. Past results do not guarantee future results. The PRT must be established before the matter is finally resolved. Tax rates: Case 1 = 35%; Case 2 = 41%; Case 3 = 40%; Case 4 = 45% combined federal + state. Attorney fee = 40%. PRT charitable contribution = 3% of gross recovery.
Reducing Taxes in Taxable Cases

Avoid Unnecessary Taxes
Why EPTC Administers the Plaintiff Recovery Trust
EPTC Qualifications
Advisors, Planners & Brokers
Attorneys, financial advisors, and settlement professionals play a critical role in identifying plaintiffs who may benefit from a Plaintiff Recovery Trust. Raising the issue proactively — before final resolution — is essential, as the PRT must be established before the settlement or judgment becomes final.
Eligible professionals whose clients adopt a PRT may receive a consulting fee from the charity. To discuss a specific matter or learn more about how the PRT can benefit your clients, contact EPTC directly.






Society of Settlement Planners
Learn More
Don’t Let Taxes Erode Your Settlements
You Have Needs,
We Have Expertise
Discover trust and settlement solutions you won’t find anywhere else – thoughtfully designed to protect assets, simplify processes, and deliver peace of mind.
Expert guidance, every step of the way.


.png)
.png)
